Mental Health & Homelessness – Part 2

Posted on August 28, 2018


70% of people experiencing chronic homelessness in Marin report having some type of psychiatric or emotional challenge.  In Part 1 of this three-part series, we looked at what Serious Mental Illness (SMI) is.  In Part 2, we’ll look at how SMI has been treated over time.

 

Supernatural Origins 

 

For thousands of years mental illness was profoundly misunderstood.  Often thought to be witchcraft, demonic possession, or simply moral shortcoming, these misdiagnoses justified a variety of inhumane treatments.

 

  • In 30 AD in Rome, the doctor Celsus argued that philosophy and personal strength were the key to recovery.  To that end, he advocated treatments ranging from the wearing of amulets to physical torture.

 

  • In 1483 the Pope sanctioned Malleus Maleficarum (or “Witches Hammer”), which blamed the mentally ill for the Bubonic Plague and justified burning them at the stake.

 

  • According to Dr. Seager’s research, in the 1700s doctors often thought physical and mental health were connected.  As a result, mentally ill patients were submerged in ice water baths, placed in physical restraints, and locked away in isolation.

 

An angry cartoon mob

 

Dorothea Dix 

 

Even though torture, abuse, and ostracization became the standard treatment for centuries, there have been glimmers of hope for more compassionate care.

 

  • The first mental health “asylums” were built in ancient Egypt and Greece.  They included boat rides on the Nile and trips to concerts. Asylums were originally seen as havens, shelters, or retreats.  They only took on the negative connotation they have today much later.

 

  • For centuries residents of Geel, Belgium, have hosted severely mentally ill people in their homes, simply accepting them as they are.

 

In the US, mental health reform is most often associated with Dorothea Dix.  Dix shared the following insight with a group of Massachusetts legislators in 1843 after observing a significant number of people with mental illness in prisons:

 

“Prisons are not constructed in view of being converted into county hospitals, and almshouses are not founded as receptacles for the insane. And yet, in the face of justice and common sense, wardens are by law compelled to receive, and masters of almshouses not to refuse, insane and idiotic subjects in all stages of mental disease and privation.”

 

10 years before Dix’s remarks’ to the legislature, the US opened its first prison in Philadelphia.  The goal of these facilities was penitence, not care-taking. Dix’s solution proposed a new system with a new goal—institutions dedicated to the treatment of mental disorders. By 1880, when the U. S. released its first demographic study of mental illness, forty thousand patients had been moved out of jails and prisons and into state hospitals. Amazingly, only four hundred people with a disorder remained behind bars.

 

Dorothea Dix with soldiers

The Forgotten

 

In a way the state hospital system was too successful. People with brain disease had a new place for treatment, and over the next 100 years, successive generations eventually forgot that serious mental illness had even been such a significant public problem. WWII reopened the issue for two reasons:  

 

  • According to Dr. Seager’s research, 40% of all military draft rejections in WWII were for psychiatric reasons.  As we saw in Part 1, mental illness did not discriminate against race, religion, or class – it was impacting Americans of all backgrounds.

 

  • There was a huge influx of returning wounded warriors who needed help processing the traumas of war.

 

As increased scrutiny and accountability descended on the mental health system, a grim picture emerged.  Books like Shame of the States (1949) began detailing the rundown and inhumane conditions in state hospitals. In 1955, with 580,000 Americans living in these facilities, Congress and President Eisenhower passed the Mental Health Study Act, creating a joint commission to investigate.

 

Greer Williams, a prominent psychiatrist and writer, was the editor of the final report. In July of 1961 he told The Atlantic:

 

Comparatively few of the 277 state hospitals — probably no more than 20% — have actively participated in the modern therapeutic trend toward humane, healing hospitals and clinics of easy access and easy exit, instead of locked, barred, prisonlike depositories of alienated and rejected human beings … [the typical state hospital] does a good job of keeping patients physically alive and mentally sick.”

 

Jack Nicholson receiving electroconvulsive therapy

 

As public support for state hospitals began to erode, exemplified by books like One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest (1962), with its graphic depictions of electroconvulsive therapy and portrayals of unsympathetic mental-health workers, this period also witnessed astounding progress with the emerging field of psychopharmacology and new drug treatments for mental illnesses. Chlorpromazine, best known in the U.S. under the brand name Thorazine, became the first widely adopted antipsychotic drug in 1955. Others soon followed, and they had an immediate impact on the therapeutic landscape. Although the effects varied from person to person, for the first time many patients with serious mental illnesses could now be reliably treated beyond the asylum and hospital walls. 

 

As a result of all of these developments, when JFK entered the Presidency in 1961, a new vision for mental health treatment was emerging.  “We must move from the outmoded use of distant custodial institutions to the concept of community-centered agencies,” JFK told legislators. To replace asylums, the president envisioned a national network of community-based mental health centers, equipped to provide “a coordinated range of timely diagnostic, health, educational, training, rehabilitation, employment, welfare, and legal protection services.” The “Community Mental Health Centers Act” (CMHCA) was the last piece of legislation JFK signed into law before he was assassinated in 1963.

 

The CMHCA – or “deinstitutionalization” as it is referred to now –  was a bipartisan effort with the best of intentions, but the results were not what policymakers envisioned. 

 

Part 3

 

In Part 3 of this three-part series, we’ll explore the current state of America’s mental system, especially as it relates to homelessness.

Close window